Rethinking Medical Student Assessment
HMS is changing how it evaluates students in the MD program
Fall/Winter 2026
- 13 minute read
- Feature
Illustration: Valerie Chiang
Illustration: Valerie Chiang
Last spring, when HMS Dean for Medical Education Bernard Chang, MMSc ’05, recorded a video message congratulating applicants who had been accepted to HMS, he wasn’t sure how the prospective students would respond to one particular piece of information. If they chose to attend, Chang told them, they would join the first class at HMS to be part of a new assessment system in their core clerkship year, one that would transition away from what has been primarily a pass-fail model for the past decade.
Medical schools typically use some combination of a pass-fail system and tiered grading, which stratifies students into one of several tiers. (Letter grades are an example of tiered grading.) But determining how to design an evaluation system that balances the different educational goals of medical school, including giving students the motivation, confidence, and freedom to challenge themselves, has been a topic of debate among medical educators for more than half a century, including at HMS.
As Chang promised in his welcome message, students who arrived at HMS this fall will be the first to experience the changes. The goal is to incorporate the benefits of both pass-fail and tiered grading, while ensuring that graduates are as prepared as possible for clinical practice by the time they reach residency. The most significant changes will come during the Principal Clinical Experience (PCE) component of the medical curriculum, during which students complete rotations in core clinical areas. The new evaluation model, part of an initiative called PCE 2028, will be fully implemented during the 2028 calendar year.
“The word ‘grading’ oversimplifies a competency-based, complex process,” says Susan Farrell, the associate dean for assessment and evaluation in the Program in Medical Education at HMS and an associate professor of emergency medicine, part-time, at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. “We are trying to create a process in which the competencies that we believe are essential for our students’ clinical learning comprise a framework for students’ required development and include those behaviors that have historically been associated with the exemplary clinical performance of a physician.”
The changes being implemented as part of PCE 2028 are the result of a process that included extensive input from the HMS community, analyses of the evaluation systems at both HMS and other institutions, and reviews of academic research on assessment in medical education, among other efforts. PCE 2028 aims to refocus students on both classroom and clinical curricula, support faculty who teach and evaluate students, and give residency directors a clearer picture of each graduate’s proficiency and aptitude. “The goal of PCE 2028 is to ensure that the physicians coming out of HMS are not just excellent clinicians, but the most outstanding graduates who are ready to be true leaders in medicine with the highest degree of knowledge and skill,” says Chang.
Evaluation Evolves
Throughout much of the 20th century, most medical schools used tiered grading. But starting in the late 1960s, many schools began to adopt pass-fail grading, particularly for the foundational science coursework that makes up much of the preclerkship portion of medical school. The change was sparked in part by concerns that students were more focused on grades than on excellence in the clinic, and it was supported by a lack of evidence that students who received higher grades became better doctors. One 1973 literature review, for example, concluded that the few studies done to that point “demonstrated that little or no correlation exists between academic and professional performance.”
A milestone in the rise of pass-fail grading came in 2022, when the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) abolished number grades and instituted pass-fail for its Step 1 exam, which measures students’ mastery of basic scientific principles. Today, many schools use a mix of systems for different components of their curriculum. According to surveys of U.S. medical school deans by the American Medical Association, 81 percent of schools used only pass-fail for preclinical courses as of 2026, up from about 47 percent in 2016. For required clerkships, 14 percent of schools use pass-fail only, up from about 5 percent 10 years ago. The majority of schools (about 60 percent) have four tiers for required clerkships: honors, high pass, pass, and fail.
The pass-fail movement was intended to address a variety of concerns, such as an overemphasis on grades and exam scores by residency directors, disparities between students with abundant versus limited socioeconomic opportunities, and anxiety’s harmful effects on student well-being. But these issues were not easily countered, and pass-fail grading created different tensions, leaving the broader debate far from settled.
Schools have tried to look to research to guide their decisions, but studies of medical education grading systems have limitations, says Alexander Iyer, MD ’26, a resident in internal medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, who dug into this topic as a medical student at HMS.
Iyer worked with several HMS faculty members to examine recent studies that compare pass-fail and tiered grading systems across 10 domains. The findings, published in a 2025 review in Academic Medicine, revealed where arguments were substantiated and where conflicting or uncertain data raised more questions.
On the upside, Iyer and his coauthors found, a pass-fail model does not appear to diminish learning during the preclerkship phase, and during clerkships it may encourage students to ask questions and challenge themselves. Iyer, for one, says that during his time at HMS, he and his classmates felt pass-fail allowed them to speak up or take on patients with unfamiliar diagnoses to augment their learning.
Many students and faculty view pass-fail as being fairer, and supporting that viewpoint, some studies of tiered grading systems found a bias favoring white and female students during core clerkships. The challenge is knowing whether pass-fail grading actually makes residency selection more equitable, says Iyer. The consensus among residency directors is that pass-fail does not reduce disparities. And the authors found that pass-fail, with its lack of easily discernible metrics, has made it difficult for residency program directors to compare and select candidates.
Motivating Questions
HMS used letter grades well into the 20th century. But in the early 1970s, the School simplified its model for preclerkship grading, adopting excellent, satisfactory, and unsatisfactory to evaluate students. With the introduction of a problem-based learning curriculum in the late 1980s, the first two years moved to pass-fail. Core clerkships remained tiered until the implementation of the Pathways curriculum in the 2015-16 academic year. For students entering that year, core clerkships began during the second year rather than the third, and HMS adopted satisfactory and unsatisfactory as the only possible grades. Tiered grading has been maintained for advanced clerkships and subinternships throughout the changes to the earlier parts of the curriculum.
Two primary reasons for the change were to reduce student stress and the bias that can occur with grading based on subjective evaluations, says Chang. But, he adds, it’s not clear that those goals were achieved. “In actuality, taking away reliable markers of academic performance might increase student stress,” he says. Instead of the stress of grades, students increasingly feel pressure to pursue extracurricular experiences, and biases of other sorts can be introduced when academic measures of success are removed.
Many faculty believe students are seeking to improve their competitiveness for residency selection by distinguishing themselves outside of the formal evaluation system, says Robert M. Stern, chair of the Pathways preclerkship committee and an HMS assistant professor of medicine at Brigham and Women’s. Sometimes this means skipping class to focus on other activities, such as research, volunteering, and advocacy projects.
“If the system says you should go do other things to get a residency, whether that’s because of how residency programs select students or how medical school is structured, people will do that,” says David Hirsh, the codirector of the Harvard-MIT Program in Health Sciences and Technology and an HMS professor of medicine at Cambridge Health Alliance.
Hirsh recently published a paper in Academic Medicine examining this focus on extracurricular activities, often referred to as the shadow economy of effort. He and his coauthors pointed out that by 2022, medical students who participated in the National Resident Matching Program had, on average, 10.4 publications, abstracts, or presentations; 3.6 research experiences; and 7.8 volunteer experiences. In 2009, by contrast, those numbers were 2.8, 2.2, and 6.2, respectively.
The increase in research output in some specialties has been particularly dramatic. In 2011, the average student matching into neurosurgery reported 7.4 publications, abstracts, or presentations. By 2024, that number had increased to 37.4.
“You feel a sense of culpability when students don’t show up because faculty have spent time putting the curriculum together and holding the class.”
“We have probably tilted too far away from the clinical space or from deep involvement in the scientific space,” Hirsh says. “One or two brilliant papers that move the needle toward cures and healing, or advocacy work that directly uplifts people’s health and well-being, would be of substantially higher value.”
Students’ perception that they need to produce ever more extracurricular work is forcing some of them to make difficult decisions, says Stern. Students may want to be in class but see peers pursuing extracurricular activities and worry that, if they don’t do the same, they will lose an advantage in competing for a residency position.
“The vast majority of HMS students do want to be great doctors who take exceptional care of their patients,” he adds. “But we’re testing their intrinsic motivation by not having extrinsic rewards.”
The shadow economy of effort affects faculty as well. Hospital teaching faculty spend significant time away from their clinical practice to develop course content, says Tamara Kaplan, who chaired a teaching faculty experience task force in the Program in Medical Education and is an HMS assistant professor of neurology at Brigham and Women’s. It can be disheartening to make that effort and then find that many students have skipped class.
“You feel a sense of culpability when students don’t show up because faculty have spent time putting the curriculum together and holding the class,” says Stern.
Learning Incentives
Over the past year, HMS undertook a comprehensive appraisal of the evaluation systems used internally and at other institutions.
“There was a sense among the greater HMS community that we needed to change something about how we demonstrate student performance,” Farrell says.
Along with the Academic Medicine literature review, a 2025 New England Journal of Medicine article contributed to the discussion. The article, by Iyer, Hirsh, and Richard Schwartzstein, the HMS Ellen and Melvin Gordon Distinguished Professor of Medical Education at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, summarized studies and suggested next steps for rethinking assessment systems. Both this and the literature review argued that incentives should be closely tied to the needs of patients. In addition to this research, direct input was collected through interviews with deans and faculty at other medical schools and Harvard professional schools about how they assess learners; discussions with residency program directors; a preclerkship pilot; and focus groups with HMS students, faculty, and medical education staff along with a campus survey that got around 200 responses.
“We asked how we can incentivize students to work hard and invest in themselves across all three phases of the curriculum while balancing their needs for flexibility and choice with patient responsibilities,” says Farrell, who led the exploratory task force. “Because ultimately, it’s the patients that we’re trying to make sure we have the best doctors for.”
At least some changes are being made to all three phases of the HMS curriculum: the preclerkship, PCE, and post-PCE, which includes electives and subinternships. The School will continue many of its current assessment practices across all three training phases but is implementing more stringent standards, adding opportunities for distinction, and evaluating the possibility of capping top marks in some components.
Assessment Revisions
The 15-month preclerkship phase for Pathways students takes a case-based, collaborative approach to learning. Students prepare for clinical cases ahead of class by learning medical and scientific concepts through online readings and video lectures and then come together in classroom teams, guided by faculty, to solve clinical problems.
Grading in the preclerkship phase will remain pass-fail, but over the past few years, multisubject courses, such as the 12-week-long first-year Pathways Foundations course, have moved to what is called non-compensatory grading. Foundations covers the fundamentals of biomedical science across 10 subjects, such as anatomy, biochemistry, and genetics. Previously, students were assessed on exams that covered all the subjects at once, so, says Randall King, MD ’97, the Harry C. McKenzie Professor of Cell Biology in the Blavatnik Institute at HMS and director of the Foundations course, it was possible for a student to make up for a low score in one area by excelling in another. Now, however, students are graded separately in each individual discipline and need to demonstrate proficiency across all subjects.
Farrell says that the pass-fail approach allows students with varying academic backgrounds to gain the basic science knowledge they’ll need when they start taking care of patients. “We want diverse students to all have the same foundational knowledge and skills to be able to learn clinical medicine,” she says.
King says that the change to non-compensatory grading will identify students early on who aren’t meeting the expected standards across all of the disciplines.
Stern adds that faculty are also considering adding a way to recognize students “who show great growth in skills.”
To underscore the importance of the preclerkship core content, students are now required to take the USMLE Step 1 exam before being allowed to progress to the PCE, a change from more flexible timing.
During the PCE students spend a year rotating through eight medical specialties at major HMS-affiliated hospitals. They currently receive either satisfactory or unsatisfactory for each rotation. Beginning in January 2028, when this year’s first-year students begin their core clerkships, proficiency will be evaluated across four skill domains instead: agility in learning, investment in learning, superior patient care, and contribution to the patient care team. “When you put together all four of those things, you come up with someone who is actually an exemplary junior physician,” says Farrell.
Such longitudinal evaluation is made possible by the PCE core faculty. Introduced in January 2025, this HMS position supports faculty with dedicated time to provide personalized attention to small cohorts of medical students throughout their rotations. Compiling the core faculty’s assessments of students across the whole of the PCE will lead to a more accurate reflection of their skills than grades from eight different instructors, says Stern.
“We want to train our faculty so that instructors in different clerkships and hospitals are using the same criteria to describe these skills so that we can be sure that we’re providing something that’s fair and achievable,” Farrell says.
Small pilot trials of new assessment and evaluation methods will run in 2027 at major affiliated hospitals, before the launch of the official changes to PCE assessment. Also planned for PCE 2028 is the introduction of a required two-week rotation in emergency medicine.
After completing the core clerkships in the PCE, students take a mix of required and elective classroom courses, as well as required subinternships or advanced clinical electives, both of which give students more patient responsibilities that more closely mimic the work of first-year interns.
Currently, advanced integrated science courses, medical ethics, and other post-PCE classroom-based required courses are graded satisfactory or unsatisfactory. Required subinternships and advanced clinical electives are graded as honors with distinction, honors, satisfactory, or unsatisfactory — an existing structure designed to signal potential residency performance. Changes to the post-PCE phase were studied last year, with decisions and preparations to be made over the next two years.
“Currently the majority of the grades skew toward honors with distinction,” says Farrell. She is leading the exploration of how to avoid such labels and instead provide other meaningful descriptions of students’ skills. The School is also studying the possibility of capping the number of students who can be given the highest marks.
Across all phases, HMS is addressing where the School’s graduates have shown relative opportunities for improvement in areas identified on the Association of American Medical Colleges’ 2026 survey of residency programs. Faculty are being asked to level any learning gaps between courses and to strengthen student skill-building, says Chang. Student evaluation will also explicitly require higher standards for professional behaviors commensurate with each phase, whether students are interacting with peers, faculty, interns, resident instructors, or other health-professional team members.
Great Expectations
Farrell acknowledges that introducing more rigorous assessment at HMS comes with some misgivings. There were “plenty of students who did not want us to change anything from pass-fail and were strongly opposed to any sort of distinction,” she says. But a grade of pass doesn’t meaningfully describe performance, she adds.
“Does everyone pass? What does that mean if everyone passes? Did they just barely pass or did they pass well?” Farrell asks.
Chang notes that students, especially early in their training, may not realize the long-term implications of pass-fail grading for their sustained learning as future doctors.
“When students are excited, dedicated to learning, and engage with what faculty have to offer, that’s what brings the highest job satisfaction to the teaching faculty.”
Iyer says that during his time at HMS, there were subsets of students who worried that marks of distinction or grade caps would increase stress levels or wondered how fairness and equity would be affected, whereas other students thought that external incentives might help them concentrate their efforts.
Stern is optimistic that more granular appraisal of skills and clear markers of excellence will fuel students’ intrinsic motivation to deepen their medical knowledge and strengthen their clinical skills. And, he says, they will assist residency directors in discerning which students will do well in their particular environment.
The revised evaluation system may require additional time and effort from faculty as they adapt to new assessment methods, says Kaplan. She believes that greater student engagement in the core curriculum will make that investment worthwhile. “When students are excited, dedicated to learning, and engage with what faculty have to offer, that’s what brings the highest job satisfaction to the teaching faculty,” she adds.
The School will monitor the effects of the new system by continuing to collect and analyze data, running pilots for the remaining phases, refining evaluation frameworks, and communicating progress and expectations clearly. “In parallel to raising our expectations of students, we have to ramp up our expectations of ourselves and make sure we’re doing a great job teaching and supporting them,” says King.
Chang says that when he recorded the welcome message to admitted students, he was prepared for the possibility that the changes to the evaluation system would lead to a lower percentage of students deciding to attend HMS. But in fact, the percentage increased, reaching its highest level in years. Regardless, he says, it was important to let prospective students make informed decisions. “We want students who know what they’re getting into,” he says, “who are coming here because they want to go through a rigorous curriculum.”
Bobbie Collins is a writer in the HMS Office of Communications and External Relations.